Ask ChatGPT or Google’s AI to name the best places to buy a truck near you, and you’ll get a short list. Your store is either on it or it isn’t. More shoppers are asking those questions every month, so it helps to know what puts a dealership on that list.
- 52% of U.S. consumers now use AI tools for local recommendations at least monthly, up from 9% a year earlier.
- Star ratings, review counts, and listings on Google Maps, Yelp, and your own website shape who AI recommends.
- Single stores and multi-rooftop groups both need accurate, complete profiles for every location.
AI Has Caught Up With Local Search
SOCi’s Local Discovery Index found that just over half of U.S. consumers use AI-powered tools for local recommendations at least once a month, up from 9% a year ago. That growth comes both from wider use of ChatGPT and Gemini and from AI built into tools like Google AI Overviews and Google’s Gemini-powered Ask Maps.
SOCi tracks about 3,000 U.S. multi-location brands across 44 industries and ran 3 million local business queries through ChatGPT, Gemini, and Claude. Its 2026 Local Visibility Index, published in January, found those brands showed up in Google’s local 3-pack 35.9% of the time and on Page 1 of Yelp 37.1% of the time, while their average AI visibility was only 7%. It has since climbed to 36.1%, roughly even with traditional local search.
Car dealers weren’t singled out in that research, but a dealership competes for local shoppers the same way these brands do, so the patterns apply.
Reviews Carry Serious Weight
Star ratings track closely with AI recommendations. Brands ranked 1 through 5 averaged 4.32 stars on Gemini, 4.24 on ChatGPT, and 4.22 on Claude. Brands ranked 6 through 10 averaged around 4.0.
Review volume can make up for a slightly lower rating. A business rated 0.2 stars below its closest competitor could close that gap with just 4% more reviews on ChatGPT, about 14% more on Claude, and 64% more on Gemini. AI tools seem to trust ratings backed by big review counts.
For a dealership, that means a steady habit, not a one-time push. Ask for reviews after sales and service visits, then read the trends. If the same complaint keeps showing up, fix it.
Where AI Gets Its Local Answers
Gemini pulls from Google Maps, and Claude appears to tap the same data through the Google Places API. ChatGPT’s most visible local data partner is Yelp, which the other platforms cite often too. Google Maps and Yelp are the top two sources, with business websites third, especially local landing pages for a single location.
Each local AI answer cites three to six sources. Beyond the big three, sites like Facebook, Yellowpages.com, and BBB.org come up often, but AI can’t always find a profile for every location. In earlier research, about half of U.S. brands lacked a Facebook store page for at least one location.
Your Google Business Profile does a lot of heavy lifting here. Google ranks local results on relevance, distance, and prominence. A complete profile, plus a name, address, and phone number that match everywhere online, tells Google and AI systems your business is legitimate.
On November 10, OpenAI introduced Businesses in ChatGPT, a beta that lets companies claim and manage their profile inside ChatGPT through Business Hub. Before that, businesses could only shape what ChatGPT said about them indirectly.
Single Stores and Dealer Groups
A single-point dealer has a smaller job but less margin for error. One weak Yelp page or outdated Google profile can be the whole story AI tells about you. Multi-rooftop groups need every store to have its own accurate listings, reviews, and landing page. A group that polishes one rooftop and lets the others drift leaves gaps where AI looks for answers.
Build a Listings Checklist for Every Rooftop
Start by auditing Google Business Profile and Yelp for every location and fixing any errors. Make your website and location pages clear about what each store offers. Keep fresh reviews coming in. Then claim profiles on other sites AI cites in your market, like Facebook or BBB, that your competitors skipped. AI tools will change, but accurate listings and happy customers are a smart bet.



